Skip to main content
Avoiding the Seven Sins of Recruitment and Selection

It’s often been said that our employees are the backbone of every company and organization. In other words, it’s our employees and their productivity, their innovation and their passion that helps to facilitate success in today’s global economy. Talented employees create opportunities to develop new products or services and/or enter new competitive markets. They are also called upon to fill leadership roles and to build synergistic teams.

Most of the HR Professionals fail to map out each step of the way or to see how each step is interrelated to making a final determination of the most capable of all the candidates presented. Thus, mistakes can be made at any of the recruitment and selection steps resulting in unexpected and unwanted turnover as well as the potential of making a “wrongful hire.”

Let’s take a moment and review some of the elements of a poorly devised recruitment process and the dangers this creates.

1. Failure to target candidate sources – Many organizations falsely believe that simply circulate a job profile and you will get long list of candidates. Frankly, this is a waste of time and energy. You need to target your efforts toward industry sectors where you know there may be candidates with the qualifications you are seeking.


2. Failure to identify organizational selling points – Managers who do their own recruitment often fail to put themselves in the candidate’s shoes. They fail to think about why someone would want to join their organization. If you don’t identify the benefits of joining your organization, and if you can’t inform the candidates of the challenges and potential accomplishments found in a job, you will fail to attract anyone to your opportunity.

3. Failure to stay in touch – The recruitment and selection process takes approximately six to eight weeks. During this time, it is important to stay in touch with the most viable candidates. Failure to do so may demonstrate to the candidates that you lack interest in going the next step. When you finally do get back to the candidate, they may already have selected another employer.

4. Failure to avoid bias in the resume screening process – Unfortunately many people do not submit well written resumes. As a result, many employers become biased when they examine these documents. Some focus too closely on dates, others prejudge a candidate if they find a spelling mistake. Still others become biased when they identify former employers and if there is a bad reputation, they then become biased against the candidate.

5. Failure to conduct an effective phone screen – Conducting a phone screen is not simply a friendly chat and a review of the resume. Without carefully prepared questions and identified selection criteria, the interviewer will pay too much attention to voice and communication. The result will be gaps in information and a failure to make an objective opinion.


6. Failure to conduct an effective in-person interview – Some interviewers make their judgment based on first impression. Thus, shy and introverted candidates are often misjudged because they take longer to develop a relationship. Outgoing candidates who quickly establish common ground often lead interviewers to focus on personality match instead of skills. Be sure to prepare your questions ahead of time, ensure they will be effective in confirming skill sets and then be sure to train all of your interviewers.

7. Failure to conduct an effective reference check – Most interviewers creates a whole new set of questions for their reference check. This also creates gaps in information and does not provide for comparison to the candidate responses. Ask references for confirmation of the different skills the candidate offers.

Failing to implement a rigorous and effective recruitment and selection process often results in hiring the wrong candidate.


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

What are the most frequently asked Behavioral Interview Questions? Behavioral interview questions are a big part of most job interviews. Employers and hiring managers use these types of questions in order to get an idea if you have the skills and competencies needed for the job. The rationale is that if they know how you performed in the past it will help give a sense of how you might do in the future. For you as the candidate, you’ll need to prepare answers (basically “interview stories”) that highlight the different competencies and skill sets the employer is looking for. The problem is most candidates might have a general idea of how to answer these questions, but the answers usually come out way too long and unfocused, and won’t put the candidate in the best light. That’s why you’ll need to make a concerted effort to create these stories and adapt them to the relevant competencies. Below is a list of some common behavioral...
Video Job Interviews: Hiring Helper or Hindrance? Have you ever participated in a video job interview? More companies than ever before are using this technology to recruit candidates. HR staff and outside recruiters often screen candidates on video before sending the most promising ones on to the hiring manager for face-to-face interviews. Sometimes these initial screenings are even set up as one-way interviews, where candidates submit a video of themselves responding to a given set of interview questions. These videos can give multiple stakeholders a first peek at candidates. Decision makers can then view, rate and discuss these candidates later (often on their own time without the need for any scheduled meetings). And for companies that hire all over the country (and globe), video interviews in later stages of the recruitment process cut travel expenses and make the best-fitting candidates accessible regardless of geography. Should you consider using video job inter...
5 Things You Have to Remember to Do Before Sending Your Resume. If you could choose between a beautifully tailored outfit designed to fulfil all of your fashion dreams or a ready-to-wear baggy tee from some random retailer, which would you pick? That’s a rhetorical question. You’d obviously want that tailored outfit. Did I mention it comes with bespoke pockets? Well, it does. In the age of personalization, we want everything to be made to fit us. So, why would we expect a hiring manager to want anything different when they get a   stack of resumes   in response to a job offer? Whenever a hiring manager posts a job offer, they receive 250+ other resumes on average in response. From that pile, they need to find the one diamond that shines brighter than all the others. How can you expect your resume to shine bright like a diamond? If you send in a generic resume that you didn’t tailor to the job offer? You can’t. Plain and simple. I know, you p...